Okay everyone, pick out a white male explorer (all are fair game) and let’s bash him!
To be fair, I’m sure that lots of people-groups have rankled a long time while some none-too-virtuous explorers were almost deified in the public image…..but this current politically correct bashing isn’t right, either.
Neither way offers a balanced view. It’s not good history and it’s not fair, either.
For myself, I’m so tired of hearing about Europeans bringing diseases to the New World, without anyone mentioning that some of those diseases CAME from ASIA and first wiped out lots of Europeans.
Let’s look at smallpox. Some history programs would have you think that Europeans created the disease and purposefully brought it to the New World just to loose it on unsuspecting Natives. This isn’t true at all…WHO suggests it may have come from India; the article below suggests Africa.
“The human disease may have originated from a rodent-borne virus in Africa. The evolutionary analysis suggests that smallpox disease slowly spread westward from East Asia, which would agree with the oldest smallpox-like descriptions from ancient China as far back as 1122 BC. It is unclear when it first reached the New World – some evidence suggests an ancestral virus arrived with early humans and diversified into a mild version there.” www.sciencecodex.com
Smallpox apparently hit Europe pretty hard, too. It wasn’t as if Europeans didn’t suffer from cross-cultural infections.
The schools-wikipedia tells us that “The disease killed an estimated 400,000 Europeans each year during the 18th century (including five reigning monarchs), and was responsible for a third of all blindness. Between 20 and 60% of all those infected—and over 80% of infected children—died from the disease.”
This disease was horrible on everyone….not just Native Americans. Maybe we should all gang up and blame the Africans or East Indians or Asians for sending these diseases to Europe in the first place! I am being sarcastic here….the fact is that diseases spread. They’re part of this fallen world, and it doesn’t really make much sense to blame other cultures for them….especially when those cultures didn’t even realize what they were doing.
Now later, there are some episodes where people DID realize that they were putting others in contact with contaminated clothing or textiles….this is deplorable and the person(s) involved should have a holiday similar to Guy Fawkes day in England….where the person is burned in effigy.
Then we hear how horrible the almost-demonic explorers were: coming and conquering out of greed; killing and enslaving Native Peoples …..forcing some of those very same Natives to take time of out their OWN schedule of conquering, killing and enslaving (sometimes sacrificing and eating) their neighbors to fight the Europeans.
Sorry, folks, not all the native peoples were innocent lambs. Human nature doesn’t work that way. If the Europeans are open to any castigation, it should be that, as at least nominal Christians, they should have had more compassion and known better.
To me, some of the worst abuse to U.S. Native Americans came from broken treaties and overt dishonesty later in history. For many of the Peoples it was an honor to them and their family to die fighting in battle, but the long years of inactivity, dishonor, lies and oppression left a bruise on their souls and bitterness in their hearts.
In the liberal school system, Europeans coming to the New World and killing Natives is anathema and demonic, but Sherman’s “total war” and march to the sea during the Civil War, burning and pillaging, and causing women and children to literally die of starvation……well that was for a good cause and completely understandable!
Truely wisdom is justified by her children.